I am desperately looking for the BEST consumer router out there on the market. I have done an extreme amount of research, but I always run into some type of dead end. I will tell you a story…
I had my eye on the Netgear WNDR3700. It is a simultaneous dual-band wireless N router with almost all the bells and whistles. I use most of these advanced settings. I was very determined to purchase this router until I began investigating people’s product reviews. They were very mixed between one and five stars. I assume this range is due to individual consumer’s technical knowledge and awareness. The more elaborate reviews led cue to this issue that the WNDR3700 has a problem with connections lagging out. I knew I could not go with this router until I either found another product or that there would be a firmware fix on the way. It was then that I discovered a product variation of the WNDR3700. I found the Netgear WNDR37AV — a product seemingly more honed towards the home entertainment system market. I began my research on this item.
I read various articles saying that the WNDR37AV had an updated motherboard and newer firmware. While I pitied those who had the WNDR3700 and received no updates from Netgear, I figured the WNDR37AV had fixed any of the lag issues with the updated hardware and firmware. Other forum postings vaguely signaled that the WNDR37AV, indeed, fixed these issues the WNDR3700 was cursed with. So, I made my purchase through Amazon.
My product was actually delivered the next day. Props to Amazon on that. I set up the WNDR37AV with no flaws. I set up both band frequencies, guest accounts, and even a network hard drive. With zero issues, I had already forgotten the many complaints people had about the WNDR3700. Everything seemed to be perfect.
But, slowly I began realizing an issue I had subconsciously been experiencing. When I would attempt to open a new tab in Google Chrome, about 10% to 20% of the time the page would not load. As these links were usually to Facebook or Twitter, I knew these sites have heavy traffic and often lag out for me anyway. But then I really began exploring the predicament, and I came to the revelation that all sites I tried to visit were often met with the same fate. And a dead giveaway was bugging out on Google searches. That never happens. I always found, though, that it was better to just open a link in the same tab rather than to open the site in a new one. I can’t explain this but I do wonder why it happens.
Anyway, where am I now? I’ve got my return shipping label printed and I’m getting a box and packing supplies ready. I’m pretty sad to have to pack it back up. It’s really a slick-looking router. I will have to set up my aged Draft-N Netgear router until I find a new replacement for the WNDR37AV.
So, now I’m back to researching… And I can’t find a newly-released router that is at the top of the charts. Other sites recommend the Linksys E3000 or the Apple AirPort Extreme Base Station. The Linksys has its own slew of issues when it comes to trying to use advanced features — and it does not support being stood on its side like I need it to be for my setup. The AirPort Extreme has no support for Wireless Protected Setup, is not designed to stand on its side, and just has a network health LED indicator. Like other Apple products, its extremely strong in the designated product category, yet it’s stripped of some fundamentals. I just don’t feel any of these options I’d be satisfied with.
I know there are some others out there… I feel like I’ve seen and considered them already. Also, many of these products have been on the market for a while. It is rumored that Netgear is even phasing out the WNDR3700/WNDR37AV. After CES 2010, I’m sure more products will be released mid-year — like Netgear set to release the WNDR4000 and WNDR3800 — an update to the WNDR3700 series. But, I am skill skeptical — even skeptical of Netgear entirely.
I know I can flash the firmware of the WNDR37AV and load DD-WRT onto it… But I feel like a product should be almost perfect right out of the box. You wouldn’t purchase a car knowing that it has a problem. Why purchase a faulty router? The WNDR3800 isn’t set to be available until June. That’s a long ways away. I don’t know what to do until then, but I suppose I will just survive as I have thus far.
44.566119
-123.265271